Files
theta-suite/docs/MULTI_SITE_SPEC.md
wmantly da60310834 feat(multi-site): auto-configure OpenLDAP replication on join/every run
Removes LDAP_SERVER_ID/LDAP_REPLICATION_HOSTS as vars an operator has
to hand-set and keep in sync across every site. bootstrap/
site-ldap-register.js (new) asks sso-manager-node's new
GET /api/site/ldap-peers (spoke) or GET /directory-admin/
ldap-replication-config (master) for this node's assigned ServerID +
current peer list, persists it to /config/ldap-replication.env, and
restarts sso-manager only when the computed config actually changed
(OpenLDAP's static slapd.conf is only read at process start). Runs on
every setup.sh invocation -- both master (peer list grows as spokes
join) and spoke.

CFG_LDAP_MMR_MANUAL=true skips the automatic step entirely, for a
topology outside this theta-suite cluster the script can't derive on
its own -- without this escape hatch, an operator's hand-set
LDAP_SERVER_ID/LDAP_REPLICATION_HOSTS would get silently overwritten
on the next run, since every fresh install starts as a master (the
automatic step always runs by default).

Bumps sso-manager-node to pick up the new endpoints + SiteSpoke.ldapServerId.
2026-08-10 23:02:01 -04:00

279 lines
24 KiB
Markdown
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Theta Suite Multi-Site Architecture & VPN Specification
**Specification Version**: `2.2.0`
**Status**: Mostly shipped. Read the status table at the bottom before trusting any section's detail as current behavior — this document accumulated across several build passes and earlier sections describe things that were aspirational when written and real by the time later sections were added.
**Target Suite Version**: `v1.50.0+`
**Repository**: [`theta-suite`](https://github.com/theta42/theta-suite)
> ## Shipped today
> - **Join, live replication, promotion** (`sso-manager-node`): a spoke joins via a one-time export over a site join key (`POST /api/site/join-keys` / `/export` / `/join`), then registers its own endpoint so the master can push live resync pings on every catalog write — no longer a one-time snapshot. Promotion (`POST /api/directory-admin/site-promote`) coordinates a real handoff, demoting the old master as one action. Identical agent-signing keys ride the same export/resync path. Read [`sso-manager-node/docs/site-join.md`](https://github.com/theta42/theta-directory/blob/master/docs/site-join.md) and `directory_spec.md` §11 for the endpoint-level detail.
> - **Gateway-to-gateway WireGuard mesh** (`theta-gateway`): real site-to-site tunnels via `POST /api/mesh/register`/`/join`, kernel WireGuard with a userspace `wireguard-go` fallback. Verified with an actual two-container encrypted tunnel passing traffic, not a mock.
> - **Cross-component routing + no-inbound relay automation**: `sso-manager-node`'s replication traffic now prefers a spoke's mesh IP over the open internet when one is on file (`utils/site_replicate.js`), and a no-inbound spoke's join (`POST /api/site/join` → `/api/site/spokes`) can carry `noInbound`/`meshIp`/`publicHost`, which drives `utils/proxy_client.js` to auto-create the relay route on the master's `theta-proxy` via its existing self-service API token system (reused, not a new credential type). The one piece that stays a manual, out-of-band step is the mesh peering itself (mint a join token on one jump-host, paste it into the other's "Join a mesh" UI) — `theta-suite`'s `bootstrap/site-relay-register.js` (`CFG_SPOKE_NO_INBOUND`/`CFG_SPOKE_PUBLIC_HOST`) picks up from there on the next `setup.sh` run.
> - **mDNS local-discovery (Linux + Windows)**: shipped and verified — `theta-gateway` announces (`services/mdns_announce.js`), `theta-agent` discovers and applies a hosts-file override, cleanly reverts when the announcement disappears. Linux was verified end-to-end over real multicast; Windows shipped in `theta-agent` v2.2.0 (CRLF-aware hosts override, `ipconfig /flushdns`, and a /32 host-route pin so the WireGuard tunnel can't swallow the direct LAN path). macOS still needs real testing — see the TODO note.
Design scale: a handful of sites (dozen max, 254 hard ceiling — see §4), a few hundred users/hosts total. This is a deliberate, small, trusted-operator deployment, not a hyperscale/adversarial-tenant one — several decisions below (fire-and-forget replication, identical directories) trade blast-radius for simplicity *because* the scale allows it. Don't generalize these choices past that scale without re-deriving them.
---
## 1. High-Level System Architecture
```mermaid
flowchart TB
subgraph ControlPlane["Master Site (write authority)"]
ssoM["sso-manager-node (isMaster=true)"]
ldapM["OpenLDAP (MMR write node)"]
baoM["OpenBao (local, replication source)"]
proxyM["theta-proxy"]
gateM["theta-gateway"]
agentM["theta-agent"]
end
subgraph SiteB["Spoke — inbound (has a public IP)"]
ssoB["sso-manager-node (isMaster=false)"]
ldapB["OpenLDAP (MMR read replica)"]
baoB["OpenBao (local replica)"]
proxyB["theta-proxy — serves this site's public traffic directly"]
gateB["theta-gateway"]
agentB["theta-agent"]
end
subgraph SiteC["Spoke — no inbound (CGNAT)"]
ssoC["sso-manager-node (isMaster=false)"]
ldapC["OpenLDAP (MMR read replica)"]
baoC["OpenBao (local replica)"]
proxyC["theta-proxy — LAN-local traffic only"]
gateC["theta-gateway"]
agentC["theta-agent"]
end
gateM <==>|"WireGuard mesh tunnel"| gateB
gateM <==>|"WireGuard mesh tunnel"| gateC
ssoM -.->|"fire-and-forget push: catalog + secrets + signing key"| ssoB
ssoM -.->|"fire-and-forget push"| ssoC
ldapM <==>|"OpenLDAP MMR syncrepl"| ldapB
ldapM <==>|"OpenLDAP MMR syncrepl"| ldapC
proxyM -->|"TLS-terminate + relay (no direct path exists)"| gateM
gateM ==>|"WG tunnel"| gateC
```
---
## 2. Every Directory Is Identical
Master and every spoke run the **same LDAP data, the same OpenBao secrets, and the same agent-signing key**. Hitting any site's `sso-manager-node` for read/auth purposes is equivalent to hitting any other. The only asymmetry is **write authority** (§3).
This is a deliberate tradeoff, not a default: it means compromising *any single spoke* — including the smallest, least-secured one — grants an attacker the same agent-command authority (`update_binary`, `arbitrary_bash`, service control) as compromising the master, because every site holds the same Ed25519 signing key (`sso-manager-node/nodejs/utils/agent_keys.js`). Accepted here because the deployment scale is small and trusted. Do not extend this pattern to a larger/adversarial-tenant deployment without revisiting it.
Consequence: `theta-agent` needs **no change** to support multi-site — it already does TOFU pairing against a single trusted key (`websocket.go:341-351`), and since that key is identical everywhere, any site's `sso-manager-node` can validly sign a command for any agent, anywhere, without agents needing a keyring.
### 2.1 What Replicates, and How
| Data | Mechanism | Direction |
|---|---|---|
| LDAP (users, groups) | OpenLDAP MMR syncrepl | master (write) → spokes (read-only) |
| OpenBao secrets (incl. agent-signing key at `secret/agent/signing-key`) | **New**: custom replicator (OpenBao has no built-in multi-site replication — Performance Replication is Vault-Enterprise-only, confirmed absent from OpenBao as of this writing) | master (write) → spokes (read-only) |
| Directory catalog (Resources: hosts, apps, sites) | Existing catalog change events | master (write) → spokes (read-only) |
| Audit log | Async batch worker, already speced (§6) | spokes → master |
### 2.2 Replication Delivery: Fire-and-Forget
Master is the sole writer (§3), so there is exactly one producer per data type — no conflict resolution, no consensus, no vector clocks needed. On every write, master pushes the change to all connected spokes **concurrently** (not sequentially — spokes are independent WG peers, none blocks on another) and does **not** wait for acks. A spoke that's offline queues nothing on the master's side; on reconnect, the spoke pulls (or master replays) missed versions.
This is a deliberate choice over "wait for all spokes to ack": with a dozen spokes, concurrent push completes in low hundreds of milliseconds on the happy path, but *waiting* for acks makes every write's latency bounded by the slowest/offline spoke — reintroducing the split-brain-adjacent stall that §3's explicit-promotion design exists to avoid. Never make a master write block on spoke reachability.
---
## 3. Explicit Master Control & Human `god_admin` Authority
Automatic failover across WAN is explicitly disabled — 0% split-brain risk by design:
```
WAN OUTAGE DETECTED
Spoke Node Unconditionally Retains SPOKE Mode
Requires Human god_admin Promotion Action
```
1. **Unreachable master**: a spoke that loses the master unconditionally stays a spoke. No auto-election.
2. **Promotion is a single coordinated action, not two steps**: `POST /api/directory-admin/site-promote` (god_admin-gated) calls out to the *current* master over the WG tunnel and demotes it as part of the same operation — there's never a window with two masters. (Requires the old master to be reachable; if it isn't, that's an operator-visible failure to resolve manually, not a silent partial-promotion.)
3. Because every directory is identical (§2), promotion carries **no agent re-keying cost** — this was the main risk in earlier drafts of this design and is now moot.
4. Site state (name, slug, `isMaster`, `masterUrl`, `wanConnected`) lives on the site's own `kind:'site'` Resource (`metadata.multiSite`), not in server memory — it must survive restarts and be visible via the same directory API as everything else.
---
## 4. `spoke.env` vs `setup.env`
A spoke shares almost none of `setup.env`'s concerns (it doesn't mint LDAP admin/JWT/service-account secrets — those arrive via replication, §2) so it gets its own, much shorter file:
```
CFG_DOMAIN=theta42.com # REQUIRED, must match the master's exactly — this is the shared LDAP base DN (dc=theta42,dc=com). Never per-site.
CFG_SITE_NAME=staten-island # this site's name/slug
CFG_SPOKE_INBOUND=false # true: this site has a public IP and serves its own traffic directly (standalone-style). false: no inbound path exists; master relays (§5).
CFG_PUBLIC_DOMAIN= # only used when CFG_SPOKE_INBOUND=true — this site's own domain, own DNS, own ACME cert, independent of the master's domain.
CFG_JOIN_TOKEN= # one-time token from the master, used for WG mesh auto-registration (§4.1) and initial catalog/secret pull.
CFG_MASTER_ENDPOINT= # master's WG endpoint (host:port) to join through.
```
`CFG_DOMAIN` is the identity namespace (LDAP DN) and must be identical across every site — MMR replicas cannot diverge on base DN. `CFG_PUBLIC_DOMAIN` is a *web-hostname* concern, unrelated to LDAP, and only exists at all for inbound spokes.
### 4.1 WireGuard Mesh Auto-Registration
1. A new `theta-gateway` boots with `CFG_JOIN_TOKEN` + `CFG_MASTER_ENDPOINT`, generates its Curve25519 keypair, and calls `POST /api/mesh/gateway/register` on the master over an initial bootstrap tunnel.
2. Master assigns the next free **site index** (one octet, used identically in both `172.24.<site>.0/16` and `10.<site>.0.0/16` per the reference topology in Appendix A) and returns full mesh peer config.
3. **Site index ceiling is 254** (0 and 255 excluded) — a hard technical limit of this addressing scheme, not an arbitrary cap. Real deployments target a dozen or fewer; no need to cap lower than the real ceiling.
4. Each `theta-gateway` applies the new peer set to its running `wg0` via `wgctrl` without dropping existing connections.
---
## 5. Inbound vs. No-Inbound Spokes
Whether a spoke has a public IP determines everything about how its traffic reaches the outside world — these are two distinct, documented operating modes, not a single universal mechanism.
### 5.1 Inbound Spoke (`CFG_SPOKE_INBOUND=true`)
Behaves like a standalone install. Own `CFG_PUBLIC_DOMAIN`, own DNS pointed at its own public IP, own ACME cert. `theta-proxy` and `theta-gateway` serve public web + SSH traffic directly — no relay involved. The only WAN-facing traffic to the master is replication (§2) and audit shipping (§6).
### 5.2 No-Inbound Spoke (`CFG_SPOKE_INBOUND=false`)
No public IP exists, so *any* external access must go through the master:
1. Master mints a public hostname for the spoke's services (e.g. `sso-{slug}.{master's public domain}`) and creates the corresponding `theta-proxy` route (already dynamic/DB-backed — `proxy/nodejs/models/host.js` — no new plumbing needed there).
2. Master **terminates TLS** for that hostname and relays to the spoke over the WG tunnel — both `theta-proxy` (any site-hosted web app) and `theta-gateway` (SSH jump) traffic relay this way, not just SSO.
3. Terminating at the master (rather than SNI passthrough) is fine here specifically because master↔spoke already rides an encrypted WG tunnel — there's no unencrypted hop being introduced.
### 5.3 Local-Direct Resolution (Skip the Relay On-LAN)
A client physically on a no-inbound spoke's LAN would otherwise hairpin out to the master and back to reach its own local site. Solved via **mDNS local-service-discovery**, not directory-side network topology:
1. The spoke's `theta-gateway`/`theta-proxy` announces itself on the local segment via mDNS (`_theta-suite._tcp.local`, TXT records: site slug, public hostnames it fronts, local IP).
2. `theta-agent`, when a config flag (`preferLocalDiscoveredDirectory` or similar — see the agent-side spec, Appendix B) is enabled, listens for this announcement and overrides local resolution for matching hostnames to the discovered local IP.
3. No match (off-site, or flag disabled) → normal public DNS → master relay. Multicast is link-local by nature, so "on-site or not" needs no explicit detection logic — presence/absence of the announcement *is* the signal. This also solves roaming-admin access (§ formerly "5", folded in here) for free: same laptop, same flag, local-fast-path at the office and relay-path everywhere else.
4. **Hard rule**: mDNS is unauthenticated on a LAN. It may only ever change *where* the agent connects, never *whether* it trusts what answers — TLS/hostname validation against the redirected IP must stay intact, so a spoofed rogue announcement produces a TLS failure, not a silent MITM.
This piece needs Windows/Mac-specific implementation and testing that can't be done from this (Linux) environment — see Appendix B for the standalone spec handed off for that work.
---
## 6. Non-Canonical Audit Logging
Unchanged from prior draft: OAuth logins, SSH session events, proxy access, and agent execution events write to local site audit tables without blocking on WAN. An async worker flushes batches to master via `POST /api/directory-admin/audit/ingest` when reachable.
---
## Appendix A: Production Reference WireGuard Topology Config
### Site 10.2 (Staten Island LAN Node) Gateway Reference (`wg0.conf`)
```ini
[Interface]
Address = 172.24.0.2/32
PrivateKey = <SITE_10_2_PRIVATE_KEY>
ListenPort = 51820
Table = off
# Mesh Subnet Routes
PostUp = ip route add 10.0.0.0/8 dev %i
PostUp = ip route add 172.24.0.0/13 dev %i
# Policy Routing Exits
PostUp = ip route add default via 10.5.0.1 dev %i table offshore
PostUp = ip route add default via 172.24.0.1 dev %i table us_vps
PostUp = ip rule add from 10.2.254.0/24 lookup offshore
PostUp = ip rule add from 10.2.253.0/24 lookup main preference 1000
# NETMAP Shadow Network (10.2.168.x -> 192.168.1.x)
PostUp = iptables -t nat -A PREROUTING -i %i -d 10.2.168.0/24 -j NETMAP --to 192.168.1.0/24
PostUp = iptables -t nat -A POSTROUTING -o %i -s 192.168.1.0/24 -j NETMAP --to 10.2.168.0/24
PostUp = ip route add local 10.2.168.0/24 dev lo
# Forwarding & NAT
PostUp = iptables -t nat -A POSTROUTING -s 192.168.1.0/24 -o %i -j MASQUERADE
PostUp = iptables -t nat -A POSTROUTING -o eth0 -j MASQUERADE
PostUp = iptables -A FORWARD -i %i -o eth0 -j ACCEPT
PostUp = iptables -A FORWARD -i eth0 -o %i -m state --state RELATED,ESTABLISHED -j ACCEPT
# System Kernel Options
PostUp = sysctl -w net.ipv4.ip_forward=1
PostUp = sysctl -w net.ipv4.conf.all.rp_filter=0
PostUp = sysctl -w net.ipv4.conf.eth0.rp_filter=0
PostUp = sysctl -w net.ipv4.conf.%i.rp_filter=0
# --- PEERS ---
[Peer]
# Site 10.1: US Hub / VPS Exit
PublicKey = QZCvR3N1CdUabC2xWfc1lmYKHfSiXYs1UoVINIMftws=
Endpoint = gg-si1.wgnode.com:51820
AllowedIPs = 172.24.0.0/16, 10.0.0.0/8, 0.0.0.0/0
PersistentKeepalive = 25
[Peer]
# Site 10.5: Netherlands Offshore Exit Node
PublicKey = MlF6h3YI1MIvOlgyNozCMoa/rICoLNtc7r/pseKiHQQ=
Endpoint = nl-alexhost.wgnode.com:51871
AllowedIPs = 172.24.0.5/32, 10.5.0.0/16, 0.0.0.0/0
PersistentKeepalive = 25
```
### Site 10.5 (Netherlands Exit Node) Gateway Reference (`wg0.conf`)
```ini
[Interface]
Address = 172.24.0.5/32
PrivateKey = <SITE_10_5_PRIVATE_KEY>
ListenPort = 51871
PostUp = ip addr add 10.5.0.1/16 dev %i
PostUp = iptables -t nat -A POSTROUTING -o eth0 -j MASQUERADE
# Dynamic Return Path Masquerading (SOURCENAT)
PostUp = iptables -t nat -A POSTROUTING -o %i ! -s 172.24.0.0/13 -j MASQUERADE
PostUp = sysctl -w net.ipv4.ip_forward=1
[Peer]
# Site 10.2: Staten Island LAN
PublicKey = AsS7aikCUrXpdfSvwFnMs0yUaoQ7ZCkoUVOmNdl7NS8=
AllowedIPs = 172.24.0.2/32, 10.2.0.0/16
[Peer]
# Site 10.1: US Hub VPS
PublicKey = QZCvR3N1CdUabC2xWfc1lmYKHfSiXYs1UoVINIMftws=
AllowedIPs = 172.24.0.1/32, 10.1.0.0/8
```
---
## Appendix B: Agent-Side Work
See [`AGENT_LOCAL_DISCOVERY_SPEC.md`](./AGENT_LOCAL_DISCOVERY_SPEC.md) — split out because it needs Windows/Mac implementation and testing that a Linux-only dev environment cannot meaningfully do. That doc is the handoff: it specifies behavior precisely enough to implement and test independently, without needing to re-derive the reasoning in this file.
---
## Status of This Spec vs. Code (as of this revision)
| Piece | Status |
|---|---|
| Site role persisted (not in-memory) | **Shipped**`/config/site.json` on `sso-manager-node`, survives restarts (v2.2.0) |
| Join key issuance + one-time directory adoption | **Shipped**`/api/site/join-keys`, `/api/site/export`, `/api/site/join`, fresh-install-gated (v2.2.0v2.3.0) |
| Spoke read-only enforcement | **Shipped** — directory-write routes 403 toward the master once joined (v2.3.0) |
| WAN health check | **Shipped**`/api/site/ping`, live in the Master Site modal (v2.2.0v2.3.0) |
| `setup.env` / `setup.sh` join wiring | **Shipped**`CFG_MASTER_DIRECTORY_URL` / `CFG_MASTER_DIRECTORY_JOIN_KEY`, `bootstrap/site-join.js` (theta-suite v2.2.0). Also readable from a dedicated `spoke.env` (`spoke.env.example`, layered on top of `setup.env`) for operators who want join-a-cluster config kept separate from the rest of first-run setup. |
| Continuous/live replication (vs. one-time export-on-join) | **Shipped** (`sso-manager-node`) — a spoke registers its own endpoint at join time (`POST /api/site/spokes`), and every successful master catalog write fires a fire-and-forget push (`utils/site_replicate.js`) at every registered spoke, which re-pulls a fresh export. Verified end-to-end in `docker-compose.multisite-e2e.yml`. |
| Identical-directory signing key | **Shipped**`POST /api/site/export` includes the master's agent-signing key; a spoke adopts it via `agent_keys.adopt()` on join and every resync. OpenBao secret replication *beyond* this one key is still not built. |
| OpenLDAP N-way multi-master replication auto-config | **Shipped** — the master auto-assigns each spoke a unique `LDAP_SERVER_ID` at registration (`SiteSpoke.ldapServerId`, same pattern as jump-host's mesh index) and derives every site's LDAP URL from its already-known HTTPS endpoint; `theta-suite`'s `bootstrap/site-ldap-register.js` applies it, re-checked on every `setup.sh` run since the peer list grows as spokes join. Verified against real running containers. Known gap: the master's own config only updates when ITS `setup.sh` is re-run, not live the moment a new spoke joins (see `docs/replication.md`). |
| Coordinated master promotion (demote the old master as one action) | **Shipped**`POST /api/site/demote` + `site-promote`'s handoff logic. Fixed two real pre-existing bugs while wiring this in: `site-promote`'s god_admin check read a `req.user.groups` field nothing ever populated (permanently 403'd for everyone), and the read-only write-gate 403'd `site-promote` itself before the handler could run. |
| WireGuard gateway-to-gateway mesh (`theta-gateway`) | **Shipped**`POST /api/mesh/register`/`/join` (join-token bootstrap), `utils/wg_iface.js` (kernel WireGuard, falls back to userspace `wireguard-go`). Verified with a real two-container test: actual encrypted tunnel, real ICMP traffic across it, 0% loss. `wg_iface.removePeer()` also cleans up the kernel routes `setPeer()` added (verified live: routes present after `setPeer`, gone after `removePeer`, own local route untouched), and `DELETE /api/mesh/gateways/:id` exposes it from the mesh UI. |
| Cross-component routing (replication over the mesh) | **Shipped**`utils/site_replicate.js` tries a registered spoke's `meshIp` first (falling back to its public `endpoint` on failure) when pushing resync pings; a spoke with no `meshIp` on file behaves exactly as before. |
| No-inbound-spoke relay (master proxies a spoke with no public IP) | **Shipped at the API/automation layer, wired into the real bootstrap flow.** `POST /api/site/join`/`/api/site/spokes` accept `noInbound`/`meshIp`/`publicHost` and call `utils/proxy_client.js`, which mints/reuses a `theta-proxy` self-service API token (`prx_...`, OpenBao `secret/integrations/theta-proxy`) and calls the proxy's real Host API to create or update the relay route — verified against a real running `theta-proxy` container (`GET /api/host/:item`'s actual `{item, results: {...}}` response shape, not the flat shape first assumed). `theta-suite`'s `bootstrap/site-relay-register.js` + `CFG_SPOKE_NO_INBOUND`/`CFG_SPOKE_PUBLIC_HOST` (`setup.env.example`) drive it from the operator-facing bring-up flow, re-run automatically on every `setup.sh` invocation until the jump-host mesh IP is discoverable. What's still a manual step, deliberately: the gateway-to-gateway mesh *peering* itself (mint a join token on one jump-host, paste it into the other's UI) — same pattern as minting/pasting a site join key, not something an unattended script should do blind. A spoke with zero inbound *and* zero outbound path still can't join at all (join/export still need the spoke to reach the master's API directly). |
| mDNS local-discovery (Linux) | **Shipped**`theta-gateway` announces (`services/mdns_announce.js`, opt-in via `THETA_LOCAL_DISCOVERY_HOSTS`), `theta-agent` discovers and applies a hosts-file override (`local_discovery.go`, opt-in via `prefer_local_directory`). Verified end-to-end with real containers over real multicast: announce → discover → apply → clean revert on disappearance, all confirmed. Caught two real bugs along the way (`mdns.Lookup()`'s IPv6 query aborting the whole lookup even after a valid IPv4 response arrived; `rename()` failing with EBUSY over a bind-mounted `/etc/hosts`, common in every container runtime) — see the commit messages in `theta-agent`. |
| mDNS local-discovery (Windows) | **Shipped**`theta-agent` v2.2.0: Windows hosts override (`%SystemRoot%\System32\drivers\etc\hosts`, CRLF-aware, `ipconfig /flushdns` after each change — reachable because the agent runs as a SYSTEM service, so the elevation question resolved in our favor), plus a /32 host-route pin via the owning local interface (`route.exe add ... metric 1`) so the WireGuard mesh tunnel can't swallow the direct LAN path, and a prompt WS reconnect on apply/revert. Tests run the real Windows write path on the Windows CI leg. |
| mDNS local-discovery (macOS) | Not built — the hosts override compiles on darwin via the shared unix path, but macOS still needs `dscacheutil -flushcache` and real hardware testing (mDNSResponder behavior, hosts-file vs. native Bonjour — see Appendix B §3). Being built on a real macOS VM. |
### TODO — what's actually left
1. **Full secret replication** — only the agent-signing key is replicated today. LDAP admin credentials, JWT secrets, and other per-deployment secrets still differ per site, which complicates full disaster recovery. **Paused pending a real-deployment question independent of the code**: this repo's own `conf/secrets.js` was found to contain committed real credentials during this work (LDAP bind, SMTP, VoIP.ms) — see the git-remediation note elsewhere in this repo's history. Building a feature that copies live secrets to additional sites shouldn't proceed until provider-side rotation of those specific credentials is confirmed done; the mechanism itself (generic secret sync, never touching those particular values) can still be designed without that answer.
2. Service-to-service auth, cross-component routing, no-inbound relay automation, and mesh peer cleanup (the four items formerly listed here) are **done** — see the status table above. What remains genuinely open in that area is documented there inline (mesh peering stays a manual step by design; zero-inbound-and-zero-outbound spokes still can't join).
**mDNS local-discovery, macOS** is deliberately not listed above: the Linux and Windows sides are shipped and verified (`theta-agent` v2.2.0), and macOS is being built on a real macOS VM where the darwin-specific behavior (mDNSResponder/DNS-cache) can actually be tested. Check `theta-agent`'s recent history before assuming it's still open.
*Committed under [`docs/MULTI_SITE_SPEC.md`](file:///home/william/dev/theta42/theta-env/docs/MULTI_SITE_SPEC.md).*